Modi Naturals Limited (MODINATUR) — valuation, ROE & quant rating

Modi Naturals Limited (NSE: MODINATUR) trades at ₹339.40 with a market capitalisation of about ₹448 crore. Its price-to-book ratio of 2.28 is above the Consumer Defensive sector median of 2.19. Return on equity of 24.20 is above the Consumer Defensive sector median of 10.69. Its P/E ratio of 10.84 is below the Consumer Defensive sector median of 26.41. The share is trading 6.4% below its 200-day moving average (Downtrend).

MetricValue
Price (₹)339.40
Market cap (₹ Cr)448
P/B2.28
ROE (%)24.2
P/E10.8
Distance from 200-DMA (%)-6.4
TrendDowntrend
Quant ratingAvoid
Alpha score0 / 100

Fundamental overview

The company has been repeatedly placed under 'ISSUER NOT COOPERATING' by CARE Ratings, leading to rating downgrades due to failure to provide information and non-payment of surveillance fees. There have been frequent Key Managerial Personnel (KMP) exits, including the CFO resigning shortly after appointment and the Company Secretary also resigning. Contingent liabilities are substantial at ₹250.46 Cr, representing a significant portion of the company's market capitalization.

Growth analysis

Promoters project high growth for FY27, primarily driven by ethanol and branded consumer segments. However, this hyper-growth is questionable given past poor revenue growth (-2.97% over 3 years), risks of ethanol overcapacity and delayed utilization, and intense competition in the core edible oil business.

Risk flags

Open interactive view →   Financials on Screener ↗

Similar Consumer Defensive stocks

All Consumer Defensive stocks →